All brand scorecards
Cookware
Caraway
Aesthetic ceramic non-stick in pastel colors. Same ceramic coating longevity problem as GreenPan.
C
Mixed
Grade C: Mixed
Some clean products, some concerning. Read labels carefully and pick specific SKUs.
What the brand gets right
- PFAS, PFOA, lead and cadmium free mineral ceramic coating
- Stylish design and broad color range
What to be aware of
- Ceramic coating wears through within a couple of years of daily use
- Expensive for the lifespan versus bare cast iron or stainless at the same price
- Lifetime warranty does not cover coating degradation
Better-rated alternatives
All-Clad
AAmerican stainless steel cookware. The benchmark for non-toxic cookware at the premium tier.
Lodge
AAmerican cast iron maker since 1896. The reference point for affordable non-toxic cookware.
De Buyer
AFrench carbon steel maker. Professional kitchen standard, fully non-toxic.
Xtrema
A100% ceramic cookware, not ceramic-coated metal. The only true all-ceramic option at scale.